Sometimes? There’s Not a Great Solution…
Sometimes? There is not a great solution available for positive advocacy.
This past Friday, my 21-year-old daughter asked me to go shopping with her. I’m always thrilled when she CHOOSES to spend time with me, so I agreed so long as it was the morning so that we could “beat the heat”. She agreed. She wanted to shop for new “under things” and I knew JCPenny was having a sale on these items. Kyersten, Chloe and I headed for Annapolis Mall to shop.
The bad thing about shopping in the “intimates” department is that there is not much room to maneuver. I was having some difficulty with my balance as well so I was just being extra careful about how much moving I had to do. Chloe does great even in confined spaces with the exception of that tail. I talk to her a great deal while we are out because it helps to keep her attention on me. Kyersten was busy looking at different styles available. My main job was to offer the occasional opinion and situate Chloe so that her tail didn’t knock things off with her loving “wag”. Chloe may not understand all that I say to her, but she does know her name and will wag as if she is paying attention to everything else I’m saying. Because my attention was on HER, and as we were in “tight quarters”, I was taken by surprise by two little girls who ran up and threw their arms around Chloe’s neck.
One little girl was about 4-years-old, and the other (obviously big sister) was probably 9 or 10-years-old. I stuttered out, “Oh! I’m sorry. She’s a working dog and cannot be petted right now”. The girls continued to squeeze and talk excitedly.
I tried to tune in a bit better and realized they were talking in Spanish. With my heart plummeting to my stomach, I held up my hand and shook my head NO saying, “Please don’t pet her. She is a working dog”.
The older girl stopped and tried to talk to me in English, and I understood “She’s a pretty dog”. At this point Chloe broke her sit/stay in order to break the choke hold. I was unprepared and went to my knees and caught myself on a rack.
With bras, panties, and tiny hangers attached to various body parts, I again held up my hand, shook my head no and said, “No please!” in a very firm voice. As I was still wobbling, I sat on my caboose to get my bearings.
The older girl said, “Oh … sorry” with some other words that I could not make out because of the accent. I did understand that she understood that Chloe was NOT to be petted. In Spanish she (I think) explained to her younger sister about Chloe. I think she realized something was amiss because I was now sitting on the floor with lingerie scattered around me. She left quickly with her little sister in tow.
I had Chloe brace so that I could get up, and asked my daughter to pick up some scattered articles. (Chloe could have, but I didn’t figure anyone else would want dog saliva on merchandise). Right as I was on one knee about to stand, the youngest came zooming around the corner with a squeal to squeeze Chloe again (who was now in a stand/stay and “brace”). I held up my hand and intercepted the young lady and my hand blocked her at the chest. Although I did not PUSH, it did stop her in her tracks. I said firmly with a head shake, “NO!” She turned and ran away.
I did NOT want to place my hands on someone else – let alone a child. I didn’t injure her, but I really felt out of options. I was “rattled” the remainder of the day. I was very upset with MYSELF that the resolution to this problem ended up playing out like it did.
When All Else Fails… Be Firm
I did look around for the youngster and never did see her or her older sister during the remainder of our shopping trip. When something doesn’t go according to plan I tend to beat myself up about it I’m afraid! I kept thinking about other options I may have had, and tried to think of what I might do should this happen again. (I’m open to suggestions – grin).
Sometimes we can try to advocate in a positive way – and the situation may just fall apart. Sometimes? You just have to be firm and resolute. We should always try to be positive and upbeat at the beginning…
“It would assist me in staff meetings if everyone would just pop a hand up before speaking so I can locate who is talking”.
“I can easily do my share of answering the phone if I had access to a captioned telephone that would provide understanding for when I don’t hear everything”.
“She’s not a pet. She’s a service dog and she can come into the store with me”.
Yet there are times we may have exhausted other options and have to stand firm.
“I need everyone to simply pop your hand up with a small wave before you speak. Thanks in advance”.
“I will require a captioned telephone so that I can do my job and share the task of answering the phone”.
“Here is a flier about what the ADA says about my rights. I’ll be over there shopping should you have any additional questions”.
I don’t think ANY of us welcome having to be firm and insistent, but there is a time and place for being firm. I try to always remember that there will be others who come after me that may also have accessibility issues. How I handle a situation may condition someone with normal hearing to respond to the next person they interact with who has a disability. There are times, however, when all pleasant and positive avenues have been closed to you. Even in your firmness… keep your cool. Keep it short and stick to the facts. My husband grins and tells me, “Denise! TMI. Keep it short! They don’t care about your background or care to hear your story”!
Accents, Foreign Languages, and Hearing Loss
The great thing about our country is the diversity. Because of where I live there are a large number of minority populations who speak English as their SECOND language. I do not speak an oral foreign language so I’m a little jealous of those who can! My mother taught high school Spanish for over twenty years, but her children never learned (much to her dismay). I have a lot of respect for people who speak English as their 2nd language. It is difficult, however, to understand language when an accent distorts the way a cochlear implant and/or hearing aid pick up the words. I have trouble understanding people with thick accents that may speak PERFECT English. I even have problems with American accents such as folks from Boston, Texas, etc. (I understand “Southern” as I lived there for so long!)
However, the fact that I have difficulty with accents, is MY problem. People with hearing loss should have patience with those who speak other languages as their primary language. I have heard late-deafened folks demean and criticize those who speak other languages. I always think to myself, “Really?” It is far more productive to explain that you have a hearing loss and have trouble understanding when an accent is present. Let them know that you are aware it is your problem, and pleasantly ask if they can perhaps speak slower and face you when they speak. I’ve overheard HoHearies blast people with heavy accents – as if it is THEIR fault! Always – ALWAYS – remember you are an advocate for others with hearing loss whether you signed up for it or not! If you are negative, critical and defensive, you are having a negative influence on how the rest of us are treated in the future. Yes, it can be frustrating and even embarrassing to have to ask someone with a heavy accent to repeat themselves again and again. But “own” the problem as yours – it isn’t their problem. It’s a big thing to be fluent in more than one language, so treat them with the respect they deserve.
Denise Portis
© 2011 Personal Hearing Loss Journal
Disabled (Grimace)
Disability (grimace). There is a small part of me that cringes when I hear that word, for often it is heard with real (or imagined) inflection that denotes a negative meaning. Occasionally, I get some “flack” from some of my readers about using the term “disability” so freely. Some folks hate the word and avoid it all costs. Others embrace it freely, caring not what the “label” may be since they are struggling to simply cope with WHAT IS. Recently, a fellow client at Fidos For Freedom used the term “differently abled”. I like that! That is the first time I’ve heard that particular variation. At Fidos For Freedom (where my hearing assistance/balance assist partner comes from), numerous programs are designed to carry the maximum “punch” in creating awareness in our community. One program is the dAP (disABILITY Awareness Program). Demonstrations are given at schools, churches, community groups, fairs, and much more to inform and teach the public about the different types of assistance dogs available, partnered with people with various disabilities. The program focuses on the abilities of all people and how an assistance dog can provide independence to people who do things “differently” as a result of chronic disease, invisible disabilities, hearing loss, mobility challenges, and much more.
Personally, I use the word ‘disabled’ freely for it is the wording in the Federal law that protects my rights as an individual who happens to have disabilities. As long as the law uses the term, I will continue to use it in order to identify with my freedoms – not my actual disability. I’m all for changing the term “disability” to something less negative, but until that happens on the federal level – I’m sticking with the term that protects my rights. Labels are awful aren’t they? I actually prefer “person with disabilities” for it identifies me as a person FIRST, and the disability second – as a descriptor, not a noun. I’ve been a member of the American Association for People with Disabilities for a number of years. They have done a lot of terrific work in laying the foundation for future laws that protect Americans who happen to be “differently abled”. Do I hope the word is eventually abolished and changed to something more politically correct? Well sure I do… but in the meantime I will continue to use a word that represents my freedom as an individual with disabilities.
Why is the Word So Negative?
Many people who hate the word “disabled” explain that it reminds them they are different. Yet we are. Acceptance of that is key IMHO to truly becoming independent in spite of a “disability”. One reader explained, “the word makes it sound as if I’m broken, or flawed”. It’s a shame society (and sometimes our peer groups) create this false picture of what a disability is. Often these negative connotations are the result of interactions with people who do not live with physical, mental, or emotional limitations that require a “new way”. People can be uncaring and mean (and you don’t have to be in junior high to experience this!). Sometimes the most hurtful things are said by people who actually care about us and are struggling to understand. Ignorance (not stupidity) is often to blame. It’s very difficult – but when you have the opportunity to correct and inform someone who doesn’t get it, do so in a proactive (not reactive) way. I try to remember that what I say may influence how this person interacts with someone else who has a disability in the future.
I believe that those who are born with a disability have the hardest time accepting the term. For example, I have met culturally Deaf people who really despise the word. (The culturally Deaf are identified with a capital “D” to identify a group of individuals who use ASL as their primary means of communication). I’ve often wondered if deaf people (lowercase “d” to identify adventitious deafness) are more accepting of the word because they experienced “normal hearing” for a time and now understand the difference because they are living WITHOUT a sense they once had? I had a Deaf friend at CSD complain that the word “slapped them with a label that meant they couldn’t do something”. I have struggled to understand that. Deaf (and many deaf) people cannot hear. What is wrong with that? Perhaps their thinking is that by accepting that label it requires the adoption of a number of other labels such as “slow”, “dumb”, “broken”, “reject”, “mistake”, and “different”. People who cannot see well without corrective lenses don’t fear being labeled with other words! Why do people with hearing loss fear that? I don’t hear in a normal way. So what?
I’ve heard others mention that the word makes them remember there are things they cannot do. I recently watched a YouTube video of a young Deaf lady who was “going off” on the fact that the only thing she cannot do is HEAR. Anything else she wanted to do she could, and she was not “disabled”. Yet the ADA protects her rights as a Deaf person to insure she has equal access to public events, education, doctor visits, and much more by requiring ASL interpretation so that she may interact on equal footing with those who use their voices to communicate. I suppose I’m a realist. I don’t understand the problem with being aware of what I cannot do. I understand that as a result of Meniere’s disease and hearing with a cochlear implant I will never:
- Be a rollercoaster tester.
- Wash windows on skyscrapers.
- Be a DJ
- Be a judge on American Idol
- Swing on a swing set (until they come up with an adult size seat similar to the protective seats for toddlers!)
- Tune pianos
- HEAR without the assistance of my CI
So what? I don’t center my life around this knowledge, nor do I attach any value to “being able to” as opposed to “not being able to”. I chose to enjoy OTHER things. 1) When I go to amusement parks I’m the official photographer. I ride a great number of rides that do not go “around and around”. I can throw a dart that insures I come home with large, ridiculous stuffed gorillas. 2) I can wash windows on lower levels. 3) I can listen to music and “ad lib” as best I can, but if it is a new song I’m lost. 4) I can be a judge on other types of panels. 5) I can climb on jungle gyms. 6) I can PLAY the piano (took 8 years of lessons!). 7) I can hear SO MUCH now as a result of my wonderful CI!
I believe that problem is that OTHERS often attach other meanings to the word “disability”. When they choose to do that, it fosters an attitude of treating a person with disability differently, or of having different expectations of them. Is this where the word “goes wrong”? I welcome your feedback and comments. As long as you don’t swear at me – I’ll post anything even if it disagrees with my own personal opinion. After all, if my desire is that you respect my opinion I can only promise to do the same. So many of you write me to give me “thumbs up”, or “thumbs down” in response to a post. I still welcome feedback privately as well! However, this is a topic I really welcome your feedback for I really am trying to understand everyone’s opinion about this word. I believe voicing opinions about this may help others! So “voice yourself”!
Denise Portis
© 2011 Personal Hearing Loss Journal
Making the World Accessible… One Voice at a Time
I love it when I have guest writers come forward to write for Hearing Elmo. There are so many different types of disabilities, chronic illnesses, and debilitating health issues. Reading different perspectives and other individual’s stories is important. This week Hearing Elmo welcomes guest writer Kacey A., who lives in South Carolina with her husband.
Because I am such a fun and loving wife my husband recently invited to join him as he completed an assignment for his Master’s program. Secretly, I think his intent was to get me to the department store so he could beg me to buy him something! His assignment was to visit a local establishment and evaluate it for handicap accessibility. He probably wishes he would’ve left me at home. Not only because I didn’t buy him a thing, but because he forgot how much of an “out of the box” thinker I am. I had him taking more notes than he takes IN his Master’s class!
The establishment we chose was the local Belk department store. It is the only department store we have here in town, so it keeps a steady stream of business. According to some statistics I found, a staggering 24.5% of our county is listed as having a disability. So, I think it is pretty important for our businesses to be accessible to all of those who have disabilities.
But what does accessible mean? When people think of “handicap accessibility“, they usually think of people in a wheelchair. But what about those people who have a disability but don’t need a wheelchair? Some disabilities require a cane, a walker, an assistance dog, or a simple chair/bench to sit down and rest for a bit.
The first thing I noticed during this visit WAS wheelchair related. There were quite a few handicapped parking spots up close to the door, which was good. BUT…because I’ve had some experience with loading and unloading wheelchairs, I also noticed that the parking spaces were the normal size with no little yellow striped zone to allow extra space to unload a wheelchair. So, if you parked with a side-loading van lift, you’d either dump the wheelchair into the row of bushes or into a car. Hmm, not very practical.
The next thing we noticed was the little sidewalk entry for wheelchairs/walkers/strollers/carts. It was made of bricks that looked like Legos, with all those little bumps on top! It’s not easy to push a loaded wheelchair, stroller or a cart, let alone push it up an incline made of bumpy bricks. I imagine it would be the same story for someone using a cane or walker. Those bumps would just get in the way and may cause more injury. I’m not sure what these people were thinking when they put in bumpy bricks but I was feeling a little pessimistic already.
But then things started getting better. The entry way was a double automatic door, which got a “double” a thumbs up because it actually gives a person some space to get in and out! In between the two entrance doors, we spotted a courtesy wheelchair, which was another thumbs up for me. There are people I know who don’t need wheelchairs on an everyday basis, so they don’t own one, but when they get out and about, they find they need one. So a courtesy wheelchair is always a great thing to have available.
Feeling adventurous, we grabbed the wheelchair and my husband (who is also a football coach) pushed me through the aisles as if I was the football he was rushing into the end zone before someone could tackle him. I held my breath, shut my eyes and prayed quietly to keep from screaming, but when we stopped and I opened them, I realized that we made it clear across the store! To my surprise, the wheelchair actually fit down just about every aisle. There was one aisle that had a ladder in it, but it was easy to maneuver around to the other side of the ladder. Once I caught my breath, I started feeling a little more optimistic. We returned the wheelchair and headed towards the bathrooms….. where things got rough again.
Bathrooms are always difficult to “pass with flying colors” in my book. For starters, the signs usually only have braille on them about half of the time. I guess those with sight impairments don’t have to use the bathroom. Of course, I can see rather well and sometimes I have trouble figuring out if I should go in the door labeled “Blokes” or the door labeled “Sheila” at Outback. Sigh.
Anyway, moving on. Then the door itself is usually an issue too. Very rarely do you see a bathroom door that has a automatic “door open” button. I grumbled to my husband about how this should be mandatory at all facilities in order to be accessible for those with walkers, strollers and wheelchairs. He looked confused. So I had to demonstrate with my “air walker” what I really meant. It is NOT easy to push a (sometimes heavy) door, maneuver a device AND keep your balance without bumping into someone who is coming out the door. My heart is happy when I see facilities that just eliminate the door all together and have a small “maze of walls” that leads to the restrooms.
So let’s say you manage to get in the door, or get lucky to find a place that doesn’t have a door. Well, you are usually “home free” then because most places have the handicap accessible bathroom stall. However, most people never even notice that most places are missing a lowered sink. This isn’t just an issue for those in wheelchairs. Some of those sinks are REALLY high for children to get to to wash their hands too. Then you have the mom who stands and lifts each of her seven kids up to the sink to wash their hands. Or she just breaks out the hand sanitizer on the way out the door.
Sigh. Speaking of mom’s. You know how most restrooms have a baby changing area? Yeah, those are great, except for this one. It was RIGHT in the way of the door. So when it was down, no one could go through or come out. Not very convenient. But my other issue with these is that they have a weight limit. What happens when you have a large child, or even an adult who needs to be changed? I have seen ONE place that had a “Changing Counter” to allow for that.
Okay, I think you get the picture of why bathrooms never really get a thumbs up from me! We finished up and my husband was getting anxious to leave, but I wasn’t done.
As we walked through the store, I noticed that besides the shoe department, there wasn’t a single place to sit down for those who may just need to rest. Not even at the fitting rooms! Chairs are such an easy and relatively cheap fix. Considering the number of people these days with fibromyalgia or arthritis that need that short break so they can continue to enjoy their day without regretting it later, you’d think that even a small department store in a small town would have some chairs!
And finally, what may be the most important aspect of being “accessible” — the employees. Some facilities may not have everything someone needs, but friendly and helpful employees go a long way. They may be able to find a chair for someone to sit down in. Or they simply smile and repeat themselves to those who are hard of hearing. They can move things around for those in a wheelchair or a walker. They can lend a hand in opening that heavy bathroom door. They smile as a person and their assistance dog walks by rather than scoffing and yelling about a dog being in the store. Friendly employees really go a long way.
People who don’t have disabilities don’t think of accessibility issues until the issue is staring them in the face. How do we train employees to be understanding in a world that wants to criticize and condemn? How do we educate people in a world that would rather be ignorant because it is “easier”?
A disabled person’s limitations and accessibility issues usually go unnoticed because the person in the situation doesn’t have the energy or the confidence to ask (or demand) that organizations do something to help them have easier access. How many people do you know who would rather just stay home than worry about making a scene somewhere? I know far too many. How do we build confidence in those around us who have disabilities to fight for their rights?
More importantly, how do we get businesses to think about these things before the “fight”? Organizations usually do only what the ADA requires and don’t think anything else of it. While I think the establishment we visited did well compared to some other establishments in town, there is still room for improvement EVERYWHERE. But how do we push for that improvement in a day when so many organizations are looking for ways to cut costs instead of increase them?
The only answer I can come up with is this – Stand up for yourself and those around you who are disabled. If you are blessed to be without a physical impairment, start thinking about those who you know who do have impairments while you are out and about. Would they be welcomed into the store with their assistance dog? Would they be able to easily maneuver around the facility? Would they be greeted by friendly employees and treated with respect? If the answer is no, then speak up. Let someone know. There is no need to make a scene, but simply let our voice be heard…. one voice at a time.
By the way, my husband got a 100% on his paper that week. So maybe he didn’t regret taking me after all!
-
Archives
- May 2012 (2)
- April 2012 (3)
- March 2012 (3)
- February 2012 (2)
- January 2012 (4)
- December 2011 (2)
- November 2011 (3)
- October 2011 (5)
- September 2011 (4)
- August 2011 (5)
- July 2011 (3)
- June 2011 (3)
-
Categories
- "Hearing Again" Woman
- ADA
- ADI
- AGBell
- ALDA
- Americans with Disabilities Act
- assistance dogs
- Assistance Dogs International
- cancer
- Challenge
- chronic disease
- cochlear implant
- cochlear implants
- deafness
- disability
- dog related
- Encouragement
- family and friends
- Fidos For Freedom
- hearing aid
- hearing assistance dogs
- hearing loss
- HLAA
- homeschool
- invisible disability
- invisible illness
- Kyersten
- Meniere's
- Meniere's disease
- Nucleus Freedom
- service dogs
- sign language
- Simple Woman
- Stress
- students
- Uncategorized
- vertigo
- Walk4Hearing
- working dogs
-
RSS
Entries RSS
Comments RSS











